Toxic Treadmill

The Toxicity of Renewable Energy

Renewable energy technologies have expanded rapidly over the past several decades as the world seeks to decrease dependence on fossil fuels. These technologies offer considerable benefits during the operational phase; however, they rely on a diverse portfolio of raw materials and complex production processes that carry significant human and ecological health hazards. Materials essential to these technologies range from common minerals and metals, to rare earth elements, silicon, and polymers. Harnessing them requires extensive industrial processes including extraction, manufacturing, processing, usage, maintenance, and recycling. Each stage has potential adverse consequences. Growing evidence indicates that exposures to toxicants released during mining and manufacturing, as well during post‐consumer recycling, can trigger chronic systemic effects. Harms include oxidative stress, neurological deficits, gut dysbiosis, cancer, and other disorders that are often misunderstood, or missed entirely, until advanced stages.

Mining and Extraction

The extraction of raw materials is the first and, in many ways, most critical step in the life cycle of renewable energy components. Mining activities for metals, silicon, and rare earth elements are inherently disruptive and frequently result in the release of large quantities of toxic substances. During mining, the disturbance of major ore bodies and the subsequent exposure of sulfide minerals to air and moisture can lead to acid mine drainage. This mobilizes heavy metals such as lead, cadmium, arsenic, and mercury into surrounding water, soil, and air. Such pollutants are a well‐documented source of exposure to small communities and mining workers alike. For example, acid mine drainage has been linked to persistent environmental contamination that leads to bioaccumulation of heavy metals in local ecosystems and food chains, setting the stage for long‐term systemic disorders in exposed populations.

Mining processes also generate metalliferous dust consisting of finely divided particles enriched in toxic metals and metalloids, which can be readily inhaled. Inhalation of such dust has been associated with pulmonary inflammation, oxidative stress, and an increased risk of chronic respiratory diseases—including pneumoconiosis and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). Notably, the particles not only cause local lung inflammation but are also capable of crossing biological barriers and disseminating systemically, leading to neurological impairment and even cardiovascular effects over prolonged periods.

Rare earth elements (REE), although not rare in a geological sense, are typically found in low concentrations and require intensive mining and processing. REE mining is especially problematic due to its concurrent release of radionuclides and co‐extraction of radioactive elements (e.g., thorium and uranium), which further compound health risks. Workers and nearby residents can be exposed to radioactive dust and heavy metals that contribute to systemic disorders and increase the risk of DNA damage as a consequence of chronic low‐dose radiation exposure and oxidative stress.

Silicon, the primary component in photovoltaic cells, is also produced via mining of quartz and subsequent energy‐intensive processing. This process releases silica dust and by‐products such as silicon tetrachloride, a highly toxic chemical that can lead to acute respiratory conditions (including silicosis) and chronic systemic oxidative stress when inhaled even in small quantities. Manufacturing environments for silicon typically involve high‐temperature furnaces and chemical etching processes that generate additional hazardous by‐products, thereby increasing the exposure risk during the extraction and processing phases.

The overall effect of mining activities goes beyond immediate toxic exposures; the bioaccumulation of hazardous substances in the local environment contributes to long‐term exposures in nearby populations. Heavy metals and other contaminants released during mining gradually build up in the soil, water, and biological tissue of flora and fauna, eventually reaching human consumers through contaminated food or drinking water. This bioaccumulation is of particular concern when even single low‐dose exposures can, over time, lead to systemic effects including chronic inflammation, oxidative damage, and cancer development.

Manufacturing and Processing Hazards

Following extraction, raw materials undergo complex manufacturing and processing operations to convert them into components such as solar cells, battery electrodes, turbine parts, and wiring assemblies. It is during these transformation stages that workers and local environments may be exposed to a different spectrum of hazardous materials.

In the case of solar panel production, for instance, advanced photovoltaic technologies often utilize thin films, quantum dots, and perovskite materials. These components frequently incorporate toxic heavy metals such as lead and cadmium. The manufacturing processes for third‐generation solar cells may involve the application of nanomaterials and solvent‐based inks via spin-coating, inkjet printing, or roll-to-roll processing. During these processes, emissions of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) are generated, and the risk of aerosolized nanoparticles can be significant. These ultrafine particles may bypass the natural filtration of the respiratory system and enter the bloodstream, where they can trigger systemic oxidative stress, neurological damage, and immune dysregulation.

The production of silicon wafers involves the reduction of metallurgical-grade silicon and its purification via the Siemens process. This process is not only energy-intensive, but also generates toxic by-products such as silicon tetrachloride and microscopic silica dust. Exposure to these chemicals can irritate the respiratory tract and has been associated with systemic inflammation and oxidative stress disorders. In addition, the chemical etching used to texture silicon surfaces may involve strong acids that pose additional dermal and inhalation risks for workers.

Moreover, many renewable energy components depend upon the incorporation of REEs to achieve the desired electrical and magnetic properties. During the processing of REEs, hydrometallurgical and pyrometallurgical methods are employed. These methods typically use concentrated acids and high temperatures to separate REEs from ore matrices, leading to the generation of hazardous wastewater and toxic off-gases. Such processes result in chemical exposures that have been linked to liver toxicity, neurological impairment, and increased oxidative stress among workers.

Plastics and polymer-based components used in wiring, insulation, and encapsulants for solar panels present a different profile of chemical risks. The production, processing, and eventual degradation of these polymers can release monomers, plasticizers, and other additives such as phthalates. These chemicals are associated with endocrine disruption and may contribute indirectly to systemic disorders and even cancer when exposure is chronic. The formation of microplastics from degraded polymer components, especially when released into the environment following material weathering or improper recycling, represents an additional pathway by which hazardous chemicals may bioaccumulate in the food chain.

The manufacturing environment itself is further challenged by the use of nanomaterials. Due to their small size and large surface, they exhibit unique reactivity and can interact with biological systems in unpredictable ways. Nanomaterials such as titanium dioxide, commonly used as a photocatalyst or in protective coatings, have been implicated in the induction of reactive oxygen species (ROS) and consequent oxidative damage to cellular membranes, proteins, and DNA. Emerging evidence suggests that even when engineered controls such as ventilation and isolation are in place, there remains a risk of low-level chronic exposure that can culminate in neurotoxicity and immunotoxicity over an extended period.

Usage and Maintenance Phase

Once installed, renewable energy infrastructure generally exhibits a high degree of stability, and encapsulation methods often limit direct exposure to toxic materials during normal operation. However, the usage and maintenance phases of these systems are not without risk. When components degrade or sustain damage—whether through environmental wear, thermal cycling, or mechanical stress—the protective barriers can break down, leading to the release of toxicants.

For instance, the encapsulants in photovoltaic modules, typically composed of plastics and glass, may degrade over time under prolonged ultraviolet (UV) irradiation, resulting in the leaching of heavy metals and nanomaterials into surrounding environments. Mechanical damage can occur during maintenance. Cleaning and repair interventions on wind turbines and solar installations may expose workers to particulate matter that includes toxic residues from the original manufacturing process. Such exposures, though less intense than those occurring during production, are repeated over the lifetime of the device and may result in a cumulative burden sufficient to trigger systemic oxidative stress, neurological dysfunction, or even carcinogenesis.

Routine inspection, cleaning, and repair often require direct contact with components that may have undergone chemical or physical degradation. In some cases, professional maintenance teams may be exposed inadvertently to airborne nanoparticles generated by the abrasion of degraded films or coatings. Although the devices in situ are largely contained systems, incremental leakage over time has been linked to bioaccumulative effects in local biota, further raising the risk of indirect human exposure through contaminated water or food sources.

End-of-Life and Recycling Hazards

The end-of-life phase of renewable energy components poses its own set of health risks, particularly in the context of post-consumer waste and recycling. Once a device reaches the end of its operational lifespan, its disposal or recycling process can lead to the release of concentrated hazardous substances.

Informal recycling practices have been widely documented in regions with underdeveloped waste management infrastructure. Open-air dismantling, burning, and acid leaching of electronic waste, result in a high degree of uncontrolled release of toxic metals, nanomaterials, and organic pollutants. For example, during the recycling of end-of-life solar panels or rechargeable batteries, workers may be exposed to significant levels of lead, cadmium, and REEs without appropriate personal protective equipment (PPE) or engineering controls. These exposures have been linked to systemic toxicity, including pulmonary fibrosis, neurodevelopmental deficits, and increased cancer risk.

Recycling operations, whether formal or informal, tend to generate fine dusts and aerosols that are enriched in the hazardous substances originally incorporated into the components. Mechanical shredding and chemical processing of these wastes can break down encapsulation matrices and lead to the production of nano-sized particles capable of deep lung penetration. Moreover, the reprocessing of shredded material often involves additional chemical treatments (e.g., hydrometallurgy) that further concentrate contaminants and can produce hazardous secondary waste streams. In addition to increasing the risk for workers during recycling, it also creates environmental reservoirs of pollutants that can lead to broader exposure through bioaccumulation in the ecosystem.

When recycled materials eventually re-enter the production cycle, there is also the possibility that residual contamination remains and is transferred to the new devices. This 'recycling loop' poses a long-term risk, as toxicants may accumulate over successive life cycles and ultimately contribute to systemic disorders in exposed populations. Moreover, the processes used to extract and recover valuable metals from waste streams are often energy-intensive and repeat pollution cycles associated with original manufacturing processes.

Invisible Health Risks

One of the most insidious aspects of exposure to hazardous substances is that many adverse health effects are 'invisible'; they may develop gradually over long periods, without immediate, overt symptoms. Chronic exposure, even at low levels, has been associated with systemic oxidative stress (a state characterized by an imbalance between the production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) and the body’s ability to detoxify these reactive intermediates). ROS can attack cellular components, leading to lipid peroxidation, protein oxidation, and DNA damage. In renewable energy industries, repeated exposure to toxic metals, nanomaterials, and persistent organic pollutants during mining, manufacturing, usage, and recycling may ultimately culminate in widespread cellular dysfunction and systemic disorders.

Neurological impairment represents another major invisible risk. Metals such as lead, cadmium, and certain rare earth elements are known to bioaccumulate in neural tissues and disrupt neurotransmitter function. Inhalation of particulate matter or direct dermal exposure to these substances may precipitate subtle changes in cognitive function, memory, and motor skills over time. Even exposures that initially seem negligible are capable of causing irreversible neurological damage due to their cumulative effect. Chronic accumulation of lead in children has been strongly correlated with lower IQ scores and behavioural dysfunction. Similar mechanisms are suspected for several REEs.

Chronic toxic exposures have a detrimental effect on the gut microbiome which is a critical component of overall human health. Research into this complex issue is still nascent. However, gut dysbiosis, or the disruption of the normal microbial community in the gastrointestinal tract, has been linked to systemic inflammatory disorders, metabolic syndrome, and even certain cancers. Exposure to toxic substances such as heavy metals and persistent organic pollutants can alter microbiota composition, reducing the abundance of beneficial bacteria and permitting colonization by pathogenic strains. This imbalance may further exacerbate systemic oxidative stress and contribute to a vicious cycle of chronic inflammation and cellular damage.

Heavy metals and other hazardous substances have been well documented for their roles as human carcinogens. The genotoxic effects of these materials include DNA strand breaks, chromosomal aberrations, and epigenetic modifications. Such changes can initiate and promote cancer development, even after years of subclinical exposure. The risk is compounded by bioaccumulation, in which toxicants are slowly deposited in tissues over the course of a lifetime. Gradual build-up of toxicants makes early detection difficult, even in rare cases where they're looked for. When overt clinical symptoms eventually appear, the damage may be irreversible.

Examples of Hazardous Renewables

Following are several more specific examples of the association between renewable technologies and detrimental health hazards.

In solar cell manufacturing, the use of cadmium telluride and lead‐based perovskite materials has raised intense scrutiny because these substances are well known for their toxicity. Accidental damage to solar modules during installation, use, or maintenance can lead to the leaching of cadmium or lead into the environment. Cadmium is a type I carcinogen, which means there is a clear link between exposure and the development of cancer. The risk of these contaminants entering the ecosystem raises concern over bioaccumulation in local food and water supplies, and the subsequent increase in lifetime risk of neurological impairment and systemic disorders.

Rechargeable batteries, which are indispensable for energy storage in many renewable systems, rely heavily on critical metals like cobalt, nickel, and manganese. These metals are extracted and processed under conditions that often lack sufficient occupational controls, leading to elevated levels of airborne particulates and chemical fumes. Workers involved in battery production have shown biomarkers indicative of respiratory toxicity and systemic inflammation, while environmental studies highlight the persistence of these metals in soil and water—an issue that ultimately contributes to long-term bioaccumulation and potential carcinogenesis.

Wind turbines, with their reliance on rare earth magnets and high-performance alloys, present another challenging example. During the extraction and processing of REEs necessary for these magnets, hazardous dusts and chemical effluents are generated. Studies have implicated such exposures in the development of pulmonary diseases, including pneumoconiosis, as well as in systemic toxicity involving both liver and neurological tissues. Workers and nearby communities in areas of intensive REE mining have shown elevated markers of oxidative stress and inflammation, underscoring the potential for long-term, invisible health effects.

Electrical components such as wiring, cables, and charge controllers, which integrate a mix of metals and plastics, further compound the exposure spectrum. During the manufacturing process, toxic additives and flame retardants in plastics may be released as particulate matter or volatile chemicals. Although the risk during the device’s operational phase may be minimized by encapsulation, exposure during manufacturing and eventual recycling remains a significant concern. These exposures have been linked to endocrine disruption, systemic inflammation, and even neurotoxicity.

Summary

Renewable energy technologies can foster increased autonomy in energy production and reduce harms associated with fossil fuels. However, the materials and processes underlying these technologies pose significant risks too, and many components rely on fossil fuel production for the substances used in their manufacture. The full life cycle of renewable energy components presents a complex matrix of health hazards that can lead to significant systemic disorders over time. The granular and dispersed nature of such technologies means that few populations will escape peril. Attempts to address the situation will inevitably lead to further demand for the manufacture and disposal of safety equipment and filtration components. A development that may simply add another layer of complexity, increase energy demands, and still fail to deal with the problem.

References